The Melian Dialogue

The Melian Dialogue is Thucydides account of the argument between the Athenians and the Melians. The arguments to some accomplishment are Thucydides own creation and reflect his personal cogitate on the invasion. Thus it is considered to be a secondary fictional character work of information. As per this dialogue between the Athenians and the Melians, the Athenians come to the Melos Island with an objective to tamp over the Melians. The Athenians take Melians with the option of becoming a colony to them, or to be destroyed. The reason for this ultimatum stems mainly from the circumstance that Melians widen their support to Spartans during the Peloponnesian War and now were a capableness enemy to the Athenians. Their freedom would mean a hallow of helplessness of the Athenians. After a long series of arguments, Athenians in the end gust the Melians and defeat them. All the Melian men are slaughtered and the women and children agonistic to slavery. The Melians pr esent a lot of arguments to the Athenians. First they argue that they lease unceasingly been a neutral democracy and that must be respected. Melians offered them to be their friends and not enemies as this would be beneficial to both.

only when the Athenians jilted their offer by saying that they would not be much(prenominal) affected by their hostility but on the intermit hand their friendship would prove a sign of their helplessness and they would be considered coward to allow such a small and undistinguished island to not be ruled by them. The Melians questioned the justice of the Athenians by asking that how fair it is to treat a neutral terra firma equally with its colonies or rebels. But the Athenians refused to loo! k at things from their level and argued that by conquering the Melians they would not only increase their step to the fore but also security. The second argument presented by the Melians was that in case of a war, the Spartans would come to their rescue as a return of favor done to them. This would result in to a greater extent bloodshed and loss of lives for the Athenians. However to this the...If you unavoidableness to get a full essay, order it on our website: OrderEssay.net

If you want to get a full information about our service, visit our page: write my essay